Showing posts with label advance directive. Show all posts
Showing posts with label advance directive. Show all posts

Saturday, August 15, 2009

End of life advance directives

Why did CMS not just issue a regulation permitting advance directive counseling as a billable service?

If I were drafting, I’d require every insurance policy to include advance directive instructions from the policy holder. I’d insist on a requirement that each of us think about how we’d like to live and how we’d like to not live. Whatever instructions the policy holder wants. But instructions.

Why did the issue become not ‘who receives’ or what one receives but ‘who pays’ ?

Who introduced the reimbursement option into the health care legislation?

Who?

Was the motivation provider greed? Or uproar creation?

Is this a Trojan Horse? That backfired?

The result was to be a payment for a service to providers, and the chance for counseling twice a decade, for seniors and people with disabilities, if one wished. But the first reaction was a scream about killing seniors, forcing people to choose to die, euthanasia, Nazis, ... And then a counter, it’s counseling, it’s optional, ...

And now the country is having a discussion of end of life, planning, advance directives, extraordinary interventions, ...

What was the hoped for consequence, and what the unexpected?

How did that clause get into the suggested legislation?



Thursday, July 30, 2009

Scuttling a good idea

If everyone had an advance directive, end of life care costs might decline, families and providers wouldn’t have to guess about patient wishes and liability issues, and each of us might start to think more about our own responsibility for our health and our own expectations.

That seems to me pretty straightforward, a win for the individual, the insurer, the system.

So I suggested that a part of having health insurance should be requiring an advance directive. There are easy universal forms available. Each person can choose from wanting everything to wanting only to be made comfortable. If they can discuss with family, friends, clergy, medical people. No big deal.

Somehow this has gotten monetized, been folding into discussions on rationing, and there is now a proposal that Medicare reimburse for advance directive counseling. Medicare serves seniors and people with disabilities; this group has become inflamed. That counsel fee is being perceived as depriving seniors their rights to be helped with costly interventions.

Sure we are talking about unsustainable Medicare costs, but we are also talking about sharing costs and social involvement.

We’d have a similar impact if everyone who had insurance was required by the insurer (public and private) to have an advance directive. That directive could just fold over into their coverage when they became Medicare-eligible. Maybe not as fast, but simple.

I don’t know who introduced the idea of associating directives with Medicare. Maybe someone was not thinking beyond a short-term budget savings, not thinking of the personal reaction. Maybe someone was deliberately trying to upset seniors with the hope of scuttling all healthcare change. It’s hard for me to understand how this good idea actually got included in the package in sure-to-fail way.